Best Self Tanning Lotion for Fair Skin in 2018? (Reviews and Comparison)

Best Tanning Lotion For Fair Skin

While it may be true that no one is expecting you to sport a full on beach-girl tan in the first days of spring, there is no denying the confidence that comes from a beautiful, yet subtle, sun-kissed glow.

The only issue is – you have fair skin. Tanning beds and laying out in the backyard simply isn’t the best option for your skin.

Let’s face it. No one has time to apply a flawless back-from-holiday tan every morning. Instead you have your eyes on that understated, buildable self-tanning lotion that produces imperceptible results.

We’re here to set the record straight on the best, easy application, quick development time, and gradual tanning lotions that you can quickly incorporate into your daily routine without a fuss.

If it's a more traditional regular sun tan lotion you are looking for and not a sunless one, then be sure to check out our article on the Best Tanning Lotion for Darkest Tan Possible of 2018? (Reviews and Comparison).

Comparison Chart

Top Pick
Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...
Runner Up
Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...
Third Choice
Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...
Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...
Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...
Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...
Editor's Pick
Top Pick
Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...
Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...
Editor's Pick
Price
Runner Up
Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...
Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...
Editor's Pick
Price
Third Choice
Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...
Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...
Editor's Pick
Price

My Tanning Lotion Reviews for Fair Skin 

1. Sun Laboratories Ultra Dark Self Tanning Lotion 8 oz.

Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...

This high-end product from the luxurious brand Sun Laboratories is rated one of the most natural looking tans by consumers. Formulated with only the best natural blend of ingredients, this product promises a beautiful, revitalizing, streak-free tan.

This easy to apply lotion requires no sun exposure and is recommended by celebrities and doctors alike as the top self-tanning lotion on the market today.

Self Tanner Ultra Dark 8 fl oz + Mitt, Sunless...

Features:

  • Organic sugar-based formula
  • Fast drying and easy to apply
  • Paraben free
  • Streak-free
  • Application mitt
  • Loved by celebrities, recommend by doctors

Product Highlights

Sun Laboratories Ultra Dark Self Tanning Lotion gives users a dark, gorgeous tan for their body and face all year round. The organic sugar-free formula is incredibly hydrating and safe on all skin types.

Sun Laboratories understands your life is full of responsibilities, chores and activities. That’s why this easy-to-apply dark formula sets in just 3 hours to prevent patchiness or streaking.

What's to like about Sun Laboratories Ultra Dark Self Tanning Lotion 8 oz.

If you have fair skin but have always wanted a dark, sun-kissed tan, then this product is one of my favorites. It’s not only easy to apply, but the directions are clear and the results are completely streak free.

It doesn’t fade into an orange or fake-looking tan, but a perfect light bronze.

One of our favorite features missing from other products is the easy to use application mitt. This prevents excess lotion from building up on your hands and tanning more than the rest of your body.

Just don’t forget to apply the lotion on your hands when you’re done using the mitt all over your body!

What's not to like about Sun Laboratories Ultra Dark Self Tanning Lotion 8 oz.

Although this product will give you a very dark tan, it seems to tan everything around you as well. This means that excess product can stain your clothes, sheets, and even the shower.

Results last for about 3 days before fading. For fair skin types, I recommend using a minimum of once a week.

PROS

  • check
    Fast results
  • check
    Smells great
  • check
    Natural-looking tan

CONS

  • Bleeds onto shower, clothes, and sheets
  • Begins to fade after 3 days

2. Famous Dave’s Medium Moisture Tan

Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...

This high-end Medium Moisture Tan from the world renowned Famous Dave’s self-tanning line is another top tanning lotion on the market today.

You might have heard of it from Daily Mirror’s 10/10 score, Top 10 in Look Magazine, Marie Claire’s “favorite,” Now Magazine’s 5 Star Rating, and Cosmo’s 10 best list. Famous Dave’s has a 15-year track record as a high-rated self-tanner.

Dave's Self Tanner Lotion Moisture Tan. Sunless...

Features:

  • Low pH = No orange!
  • Moisturizing
  • Anti-aging, firming Ingredients
  • Formulated for men and women

Product Highlights

Famous Dave’s Self Tanning Lotions have been developed over years and years. Having worked closely with plastic surgeons in the MediSpa industry, Famous Dave’s implement a collection of ingredients proven for anti-aging and anti-orange.

This highly moisturizing lotion not only makes you look good, but makes you feel good too.

What's to like about Famous Dave’s Medium Moisture Tan

Famous Dave’s understands what people want out of self-tanner. Above all, I think it’s safe to say that no one wants to look orange.

Other tanning lotions on the market contain ingredients such as Mineral Oil and Stearic Acid. These are high in pH. High pH = the color orange! Famous Dave’s doesn’t contain any ingredients like these that might prevent you from looking like your most natural self.

Plus, it contains anti-aging and firming ingredients to promote youthful skin. The smell is appealing for both men and women.

What's not to like about Famous Dave’s Medium Moisture Tan

Although this product is highly rated in its ingredients, some consumers feel like it takes a bit of practice to apply evenly and that it isn’t as fast drying as other available products.

As the tanner fades it can appear blotchy and uneven. Dark results are not immediate and may take some time to develop.

PROS

  • check
    High-end anti-aging ingredients
  • check
    No orange
  • check
    Appealing smell for both men and women

CONS

  • Not fast drying
  • Difficulty in even application
  • Fades blotchy and uneven
  • Delayed results

3. Sun Laboratories Tan Overnight Fair to Medium Skin Tones Lotion 32 oz.

Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...

Yes, Sun Laboratories made our list again. Their products are just that good. This high-end overnight self-tanning lotion is specially formulated for fair to medium skin tones.

The best part? You can fall asleep and wake up as the bronze goddess you always knew you were!

Value Size Sunless Tanning Lotion - Ultra Dark 32...

Features:

  • Natural looking, instant tan
  • Moisturizing for all skin types
  • Quick drying
  • Overnight application
  • Streak free
  • Easy to Use application mitt

Product Highlights

Sun Laboratories Self Tan Overnight Lotion 32 oz. is designed for professional applications. Its easy-to-use pump design and application mitt help you create the most natural looking tan.

The ultra-dark formula helps you easily see if you have missing any areas to ensure the most even tan. The formula is extremely quick drying working to tan and revitalize your skin while you sleep without streaking, greasiness, or stickiness.

What's to like about Sun Laboratories Tan Overnight Fair to Medium Skin Tones Lotion 32 oz.

We love how well this product worked on pale skin types. Not only does it render a dark tan, it’s completely easy to apply.

The formula doesn’t cause streakiness or orangey color. You truly wake up feeling like a bronze goddess after using this product.

What's not to like about Sun Laboratories Tan Overnight Fair to Medium Skin Tones Lotion 32 oz.

This product can get MESSY very easily. Be careful when applying near any clothes or towels.

It can and will stain the things around you. Some users claim that it can rub off into sheets at night.

PROS

  • check
    Beautiful, natural looking tan
  • check
    Easy and even application
  • check
    Won’t blotch or streak

CONS

  • Messy application
  • May rub off into sheets

FINAL VERDICT

Fair Skinned Tanning Lotion

If you have fair skin and are looking for quick tanning results, then Sun Laboratories Tan Overnight Fair to Medium Skin Tones Self Tanning Lotion is your best bet. The lotion is one of the easiest to apply, renders the darkest most natural looking results, and doesn’t fade into streaks or blotchiness.

This is the best way to get an instant dark sun-kissed tan if you have fair skin. If you don’t like the idea of leaving it on your skin overnight, then we recommend Sun Laboratories Ultra Dark Tanning Lotion for a quick and fast-drying day application.

Last update on 2018-05-27 at 17:16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*